Planning Watch: After President Harry Truman fired General Douglas MacArthur, the general gave a farewell speech to Congress that is remembered for its closing line, ”Old soldiers never dies, they just fade away.”
This maxim, however, does not apply to discredited planning ideas. They don’t die or fade away. Instead they resurface with new names and justifications for continued real estate speculation. The best example is public programs that allow private real estate developers to acquire old commercial property so they can build highly profitable in-fill ventures. In the post-war era, these abandoned government programs were called Urban Renewal. They allowed cities to form agencies, such as LA’s former Community Redevelopment Agency, that used eminent domain to acquire commercial real estate parcels, evict the tenants, demolish buildings, and then reassemble the parcels for private…